I finally read the Boundaries book as promised, and I wasn't too impressed. I found that it was rather vague, at the end I still didn't have a very good grasp on what they are, the purpose of them, how to know if we have them or not, and how we establish them with ourselves and with others in a loving and healthy way. I did learn these are the effects of poor boundaries though (he explains them better in the book).
-depression (lack of them allows us to be treated poorly resulting in resentment and hurts)
-panic/anxiety (due to lack of perceived control over our lives)
-resentment/martyr syndrome (doing things out of obligation from others)
-passive-aggressiveness (same as last one)
-codependency (taking on responsibility for the behaviors of other adults, this can also sometimes include enabling sin and evil)
-identity confusion (we don't know what is our responsibility and what is someone else's, what a heavy burden)
-difficulties in being alone (they have no identity of their own, so cannot hold love and need constant reassurance and love from others, the cup is never filled though)
-masochism (cannot set limits on abuse of themselves or others, think they don't deserve it)
-over-responsibility and guilt (feel responsible for others safety, well-being and happiness, cannot ever do enough to meet those needs though)
-under-responsibility (those who are keeping track of others so much often neglect the needs in their own lives)
-feelings of obligation (same as last ones) 1 Cor 9:7
-victim mentality (life happens TO them, and they had no choice or responsibility in it)
-blaming (goes along with victimhood. Takes no responsibility for their own feelings, action or behaviors, they all must be blamed on someone else)
-feelings of being let down (since they spend so much time taking care of others, they feel others should do the same for them)
-isolation (due to lack of boundaries, there comes distorted thinking and a lack of freedom, so relationships are eliminated to avoid potential conflict so they never have to feel controlled or invaded, they choose isolation instead of healthy boundaries)
-extreme dependency (they have never felt a feeling of owning their own life so often fuse their life with someone else to avoid ownership. They are very fearful of separateness)
-disorganization and lack of direction (they often cannot choose goals, likes and dislikes, they lack direction and purpose)
-substance abuse and eating disorders (feel out of control in their lives so use substances to dull their pain and make a few of their own choices)
-obsessive-compulsive behaviors (people turn their lack of control about life against themselves, since they can't control others. Learning healthy boundaries helps to fix this)
-procrastination (this is from not being able to say no, the parable of the two sons in Matt 21 explains further)
-impulsivity (lacking internal structure, they are unable to say no to impulses and urges, cannot be honest with themselves)
-generalized anxiety (again, no internal structure to feel safe, so always feel anxious)
Here's a few questions to ask you about your boundaries with others. Do you tend to do the first question in each, or the second? I'm guilty of the first most my life, unfortunately. Slowly learning!
It can also lead to high functioning anxiety, which looks pretty good from the outside~
In that book though, he mentioned another book he has written called
Changes that Heal that I already had sitting on my shelf, and so, after reading this one the pieces have started to come together.
He starts out by listing the 4 things we need to learn to grow up to be an adult. Often (for various reasons) we neglect to learn some or all of these things. It sounds pretty simple summed up here, but when you read the book you can see how complex these processes are in light of God's Word and our exposure to the world (our family, our schools, our churches, our friends, etc). He first goes into learning proper distinctions and definitions of the words grace and truth, and how time (to learn and grow) plays into it all.
- Bond with others – To connect in a meaningful way with other humans
- Separate from others – Learn when and how to be apart from others
- Sort out issues of good and bad – Identify what is good for us and bad for us
- Take charge as an adult – Be in peer relationships where you have to take responsibility appropriately
Sometimes the biggest challenge to working on an issue is getting past the defenses. Some of the defenses that we have against seeing our own limitations are so powerful that they deny reality. They prevent us from realizing that we’re using defenses. It becomes our greatest challenge to see ourselves with integrated self-images – to recognize ourselves for both our good and our bad qualities. Here’s a list of common defenses that we all use:
- Denial – We simply deny that we have any problems. We’re focused completely on the fact that we’re without fault – or at least this fault.
- Devaluation – Yes but… The love and connection that is offered to me is devalued so that it doesn’t count. The emotional isolation I’m experiencing isn’t my fault because the connections that are being offered to me aren’t valuable.
- Projection – This is the act of taking your feeling and ascribing it to someone else because you don’t want to own it. “I’m not angry; you’re angry – and it’s making me angry.”
- Reaction Formation – This is saying that I’m the opposite of what I’m really feeling. Instead of saying I feel sad I say that I feel happy.
- Mania – I’m hyperactive but disorganized.
- Idealization – I visualize myself as perfect. I believe that it’s impossible to have a fault because I’m perfect. (we'd never admit this of course!)
By contrast, here are the things you do when you’re moving into the wound and the process of healing:
- Realize the Need – I accept that I have a need be bonded and attached to others.
- Move Towards Others – I recognize that I have to move towards others – not expect they will always move towards me.
- Be Vulnerable – I must be vulnerable to get close to others. If I live behind impenetrable walls no one will ever be able to get close.
- Challenge Distorted Thinking – I recognize that my perception is distorted and that some thoughts and feelings distort it further.
- Allow Dependent Feelings – I have to allow a level of attachment to another person to be connected to them. I must care about them.
- Become Comfortable with Anger – Anger is disappointment directed. I can use anger as a tool to better understand my relationship to others.
- Be Empathetic – I need to share (or mirror) others’ thoughts, feelings, and emotions to truly connect with them.
- Rely on the Holy Spirit – I have insufficient power on my own, but through the Holy Spirit I can.
- Say Yes to Life – I must internalize that to be fully alive is to be connected with God and others.
10 Skills for Becoming an Adult
- Reevaluate Beliefs – I reevaluate my beliefs based on what I know. Humans are lousy at reprocessing what we know when our awareness and values change.
- Respectful Disagreement with Authority Figures – I acknowledge and accept my disagreements with authority figures – and choose healthy ways of dealing with them.
- Make Your Own Decisions – I don’t allow others to make decisions for me – I own my own life.
- Practice Disagreeing – I need to accept that disagreeing with others is natural and healthy.
- Deal with Your Sexuality – “‘Children don’t talk about sex’, but adults can. Stop whispering!”
- Recognize and Pursue Talents – I will practice the skills that I’ve been given – with acceptance that failure is a pathway to growth.
- Discipline Yourself – I will be responsible for my own discipline.
- Gain Authority Over Evil – I have the ability to resist evil and temptation.
- Submit to Others out of Freedom – I will submit to others out of love and respect for them.
- Appreciate Mystery and the Unknown – I recognize that I’ll never know everything. I’ll accept that there are things that I cannot know.
Here's a review below by someone else that sums it up a bit differently, I'm just going to copy and paste. Lots to ponder!
Changing in Him
In the course of Henry Cloud’s own spiritual and professional journey, he has identified four aspects of the personality of God that, if we would cultivate them, would greatly improve our day-to-day functioning. God is able to do four things that we, his children, have difficulty doing:
1. Bond with others.
2. Separate from others.
3. Sort out issues of good and bad.
4. Take charge as an adult.
Without the ability to perform these basic functions, we can literally remain stuck for years, and growth and change can elude our grasp. In this blog I will explain these four developmental tasks, the barriers that get in the way of our achieving them, and the skills we need for completing them.
Pillar #1 Learning to Bond
Having good emotional connections is as natural as a plant taking in water. But we are not plants living in the Garden of Eden. Therefore, we require some serious gardening in order to bear fruit. The fig tree gardener planned to “dig around and fertilize” the tree that wasn’t bearing any fruit for a year to help it bear fruit.
Making human connections when you grew up without them takes a good dose of grace, truth, and time. Here are some skills that will start you on the long road to making changes that heal.
You may not realize that your problems now stem from a lack of bonding and attachment. Perhaps you grew up in a family where closeness was not valued, or were injured to the point where you have forgotten how to bond. Thus, the first thing you need to do is to realize how much you need attachment.
This is wonderful when others move toward you and seek out your heart, for that is what God does. Often, though, others cannot see what you need and how emotionally isolated you really are.
Being vulnerable at a social level may be too threatening at first. Maybe you need to start with a pastor, counselor, or support group. But vulnerability is a skill that opens up the heart for love to take root. When you can admit that you need support and help, and can reveal your hurt and isolation, a dynamic is set into motion that can literally transform your personality and life.
- Challenge distorted thinking
If you don’t, for example, challenge the belief that “all people will leave me,” you will never form an abiding attachment, and you will re-create the isolation of your past. The Lord has promised to reveal the truth to you. Ask him to show you your particular distortions.
To learn new relational skills and the way of attachment, take risks.
Whenever you begin to allow someone to matter to your isolated heart, uncomfortable needy and dependent feelings will surface. These are the beginnings of a softening heart. Though uncomfortable, these feelings are a key to attachment.
Empathy is the ability to share in another’s emotions, thoughts, or feelings. Empathizing with others’ needs, identifying with their hurt, softens your own heart.
Pillar #2 Learning to Set Boundaries
Stephen was burned out and on the verge of losing his job because he could never say no to people’s requests for help. Sandy was unhappy and out of control of her life because she couldn’t say no to her mother. Jane suffered panic attacks because she couldn’t say no to her husband’s drinking. Jim was unhappy because he could never say no to his wife’s requests to work around the house.
Let’s look at some of the skills necessary for setting boundaries and learning to say no when someone tries to cross those boundaries.
Since setting boundaries is merely taking ownership of what is yours, your first step is gaining awareness of who you are. Become aware of your body, feelings, attitudes, behaviors, thoughts, abilities, choices, wants, and limits. Take inventory of where you have come from, where you are now, and where you are going.
Just as God defines Himself, you need to assert yourself. Begin to say what you feel, what you like, what you want, what you will do, and what you think. Carve out an identity and say, “This is who I am.”
You must also say who you are not. Say what is “not you,” as well as what is you. Say what you don’t agree with, don’t like, won’t do, and so on. People with boundary problems often do not stand against anything. They take everything in. This is very destructive. In Proverbs 6, God calls us to stand against and hate some things.
A child learns to set boundaries by saying no. Many of us have eliminated this word from our vocabulary, and we need to rediscover it. Strengthen your no muscle. Begin with little exercises, such as saying no to dining at a certain restaurant that you don’t want to go to, and work your way up to more demanding ones. Learning to say no is probably the most important and difficult task in creating boundaries, especially saying no to parents.
Taking responsibility for your own pain and not blaming others is a major move out of bondage and into health. Stop blaming others for your trouble, and deal with it. This does not mean that others did not cause it; it just means that you have to deal with it. Blaming others is a dead-end street.
As an adult, you have choices. Begin to take responsibility for those choices and own them. If you are giving something, you are making a choice to give and you need to stop acting as if someone is making you give. As an adult, you are choosing. If you are working somewhere that you don’t like, take responsibility for finding something else. If you are being criticized over and over by a friend, take responsibility to set up a meeting with him or her. You are responsible for what you choose to do. Taking this responsibility will change your life.
God commands us to persevere, or to continue on in spite of difficulty or opposition. "Wherefore seeing we also are compassed about with so great a cloud of witnesses, let us lay aside every weight, and the sin which doth so easily beset us, and let us run with patience the race that is set before us, Looking unto Jesus the author and finisher of our faith; who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, despising the shame, and is set down at the right hand of the throne of God. For consider him that endured such contradiction of sinners against himself, lest ye be wearied and faint in your minds". (Heb. 12:1–3).
Be honest with others. Many people will not be honest because they fear loss of intimacy and togetherness. In reality, honesty brings people closer together, for it will strengthen their identities. The more you realize your separate identities, the closer you can become. Telling loved ones what is really on your mind, and telling others what you really think, is the foundation of love.
Pillar #3 Learning to Accept Both Good and Bad
Growth does not come without effort. Many skills must be learned and practiced in order to resolve issues of the good and the bad. Here are some.
Besides confessing your sins, ask God to make you aware of things you may be ignoring. David prayed, “Search me, O God, and know my heart: try me, and know my thoughts: And see if there be any wicked way in me, and lead me in the way everlasting.” (Ps. 139:23–24).
Ask God to shine his light into your soul and reveal anything that you are unaware of. Then ask his forgiveness for it and confess it to other trusted Christian(s) as necessary.
Much of the content of our ideal self is false; it is not what an ideal person would be. Check out what needs to be eliminated from your picture of what an ideal you would be. You may need to delete some ideals that come from your family or the culture, instead of from God.
Challenge your distorted views of God, yourself, and others. These strongly held beliefs don’t give way easily, but in new relationships, you can unlearn them. Study the Scriptures to see what they say about our ideal, our reality, and what God and salvation are really like.
- Monitor the relationship between the ideal and the real
Listen to the way you respond to the less than ideal. Do you deny it? Do you deny the good? Do you attack and judge? Do you accept and forgive? Many people are stunned to find out how much they attack themselves and others.
- Practice loving the less than ideal in others
Learning to accept badness and weakness in others brings healing in the split of the good and bad. Stay connected to others when they are less than ideal, and you will begin to value real relationship and stop demanding idealism. In this way, attachment increases, and your ability to love grows. The less than ideal begins to matter more than the ideal because you have a real relationship.
- Do not discard others when they are less than perfect
If you have had trouble with going from friend to friend, spouse to spouse, church to church, because you find some little flaw and make them all bad, work on staying in connection and working out the problem. Actively see the good as well as the bad, and love the whole person. Make reality your friend instead of your enemy.
- Process and value negative feelings
When you are committed to reality, to both the good and the bad, you will begin to see negative feelings as a part of life. If you fear them less, you can then process them as they arise and avoid all the problems listed in the last chapter. Most problems with negative feelings come from a fear about them. They really are not as bad as you fear they are. Negative feelings will not kill you, but avoiding them may.
- Expect badness and weakness from everyone
I’m not suggesting you turn into a pessimist. I’m saying, “Be a realist.” Everyone you know, including yourself, has good and bad, strengths and weaknesses. Therefore, expect to see them in action. When the faults come, embrace them and love them so that you can overcome your splitting of good and bad as well as feel closer to others.
Pillar #4 Learning to Become Mature Adults
Learning to become an adult is not an easy task. Perhaps becoming an adult while you’re already living in an adult body is even harder. But it is a necessary step to take to get out from under the authority of others.
Here are some of the skills you will need to become your own master under God, to become a mature adult.
We need to reevaluate what we believe. The time is past for “inherited beliefs”; it is time for an adult faith. We need to look into why we think what we think and why we believe what we believe. Is it because we really believe it, or because someone told us to believe it? We need to recognize what is a belief of “tradition” versus what is a real heartfelt conviction from God, his Word, and our own experience. This questioning period could last awhile. But, when we are through, we will have developed a mind of our own.
- Disagree with authority figures
Be honest about your disagreements with others. Most people have disagreements with authority figures, but they are afraid to admit to themselves how strongly they disagree. And they are afraid to voice their disagreements. If you are in a group where you are not free to have a different opinion on gray issues, be careful. Your group may have cult-like qualities.
- See parents and authority figures realistically
Knock parents and other authority figures off the pedestal you’ve put them on. See their weaknesses as well as their strengths. Look at the ways you disagree with what they believe and think. Since no two people agree on everything, search your life for anyone with whom you agree on everything, or who you think has it all together. You may be either unaware of how you disagree, or you may be a flatterer.
If people in your life are telling you what to think, believe, do, or buy, start making those decisions yourself. You are an adult; learn to think and act for yourself. Who cares if someone disapproves of the purchase you make? It’s your money, and how you spend it is between you and God.
If you are prudish or embarrassed by sex, your parents may still be looking down their nose at your sexuality, or at least that’s the way you are perceiving it. Work on reeducating yourself about the beauty of sex; desensitize yourself to the “no-no” attitude you have toward it. If you feel ashamed, you may still be in a preadolescent stage regarding sex.
- Recognize and pursue talents
To become an adult requires that you own and recognize the talents and gifts God has given you. You may be aware of some area that you are gifted in, and God has been telling you to develop it in some way, but you have been burying that talent in the ground.
This is important to develop whatever skill and expertise you are considering. You can’t learn to be an authority and have expertise in an area if you don’t have the freedom to practice and learn. Give yourself permission to fail.
- Appreciate mystery and the unknown
One of the hallmarks of people with authority problems is their inability to tolerate mystery and the unknown. They need an answer for everything, and everything has to be wrapped up in neat little packages. Jesus kept trying to shake the Pharisees out of this rigidity.
In many ways God is “unsearchable” (Rom. 11:33–34). He is so awesome that the more we know him, the more we realize we don’t know. This is where worship begins. It is his very transcendence that we worship. Begin to appreciate the things that you cannot figure out about Him, and let them be. This is why we call him “God.” If you can know everything about him, then he is no longer God; you are. This is the most serious authority problem of all.
Worship his mystery. Get out of the black-and-white “we-have-all-the-answers” mentality that keeps God in a box. He is much greater than that.
Symptoms of Failing to Become an Adult
(which are each explained in depth in the book)
- Inordinate need for approval
- Fear of disapproval
- Guilt
- Sexual struggles
- Fear of failure
- Need for permission
- "You can't do that" syndrome
- Feelings of inferiority
- Competitiveness
- Loss of power
- No equal differences
- Black-and-white thinking
- Judgementalism
- Anxiety attacks
- Impulsiveness and Inhibition
- Superiority
- Parenting other adults
- Hate/fear of authority figures
- Depression
- Dependency
- Idealization of authority
- Idealization of childhood
A few more thoughts~
- Many of us have a problem confessing our sins to others. We think it will show weakness or that people will judge us as less than perfect (above reproach!) We want to be a "good witness" or a "good example", but truthfully the root of all of this is pride and self-righteousness. A good witness would be one who witnesses how forgiving God is, not how perfect we are (this is often by our actions, not necessarily our words would say this). He who is forgiven much, loveth much. (Luke 7:47) We need to seek forgiveness in specifics, not generalities too, as this is easy to do. It's much easier to confess light things like generalized anger, impatience, etc rather than the deepest darkest parts of our souls which become a cancer to our bodies, later coming out in psychological and physical problems instead.
- We need to recognize as adults that in Christ there are no step-up or step-down relationships. We are all sinners in need of salvation, we are all level at the foot of the cross. We are all easily led astray by the devil, the world and our own flesh, and we all need admonishment and encouragement from the body of believers (regular fellowship). None of us are exempt from this, and none of us are above anyone else in the kingdom of God. We are all peers, if we have the Holy Spirit. Anytime we put ourselves above someone else, we become Pharisees. Anytime we put ourselves below someone else, we don't recognize our intrinsic value that God made us in His own Image.
- Difference of opinion/belief doesn't mean someone is right so the other person must be wrong. We may both be right in different ways, and we can also both easily be wrong. When we look for the wrong in others (to prove we are right), we end up creating barriers to love and forgiveness and grace. If we are only looking for the wrong/badness, we are sure to find it! This is called black-and-white thinking and it is very juvenile. There are many shades of gray on just about every subject.
Whew! That's all folks!